Recent Articles

EFF Launches Net Neutrality Tool
The Electronic Frontier Foundation has introduced a new tool that allows users to find out if their ISPs are throttling their P2P files. The new "Switzerland Tool" will reveal if a user's network connection has any any restrictions on it from ISPs. "It's up to concerned...

SQL Server Upgrade Database Mirroring Issues
Before upgrading our production servers I simply removed the mirroring with the wizard. After the upgrade process the last step was to recreate the mirroring. If you have done this you know that you need to do a full backup with transaction log backup of the db and...

Reactions To European Telecommunications Packet...
Today the European Parliament is going to vote on proposed amendments to the telecommunications packet regulation, below an excerpt of FFII press release and Kathy Sinnott reactions. European Parliament rushes towards Soviet Internet. Brussels, 04 July 2008...

RIAA Demands ISP's To Spy On Their Users
ISP's are beginning to bow to RIAA demands and spying on their users. This is odd if you consider them a communications company... like the telephone companies are. For example, do you talk on...

Network Access Control Is Achievable
Network Access Control (NAC) promises to allow only authorized and compliant devices to access and operate on a network. If implemented properly, NAC can improve the security profile of a network and lower the overall security risks faced by an enterprise. The various...



08.11.08

FCC Declares Comcast's Filtering Illegal

By Jason Lee Miller

It's official, as far as the FCC is concerned, that Comcast's throttling of peer-to-peer traffic was illegal and in violation of the FCC's network neutrality principles. The highly expected ruling came down a few days ago, with Chairman Kevin Martin crossing the political aisle to join commissioners Copps and Adelstein, serving Comcast with a cease-and-desist order.

Don't expect it to be the last word, though. The ruling, as it is, is more of a symbolic victory. Comcast will not be fined, but is ordered to stop interfering with subscribers' access to peer-to-peer networks, something the cable giant already volunteered to do in April when things started getting hot. The ruling requires Comcast to disclose the details of its discriminatory management practices, submit a compliance plan about how it will stop these practices by the end of the year, and disclose the network management practices that will replace the current ones.

And if they don't? Well, let's let the current battle go to the courts before we worry about that. In 2006, the Republican Congress five times rejected bills giving the FCC the authority to enforce network neutrality, and a Supreme Court ruling also declared the FCC had no authority to act unless Congress gave the agency that authority. Political opponents on the other side have argued the FCC does indeed have the authority, granted under the Communications Act.

Definite authority is included in the proposed Internet Freedom and Preservation Act, which has yet to pass. Until then, the FCC believes it can indeed punish Comcast and other ISPs for net neutrality violations. So what we have facing is a true test of authority rather than a concrete victory for nondiscrimination.

Save Valuable Time and Resources with the
Peer1 ValuePro Managed Hosting Plan

Commissioner Copps made a curious comment, after the 3-2 vote, acknowledging discrimination wasn't necessarily illegal, but "unreasonable discrimination" is. Comcast initially denied interfering with p2p traffic and was made a liar by the Associated Press; Comcast then admitted to interfering, but not blocking, only during peak hours. More independent tests showed Comcast was blocking at all times of day, on par with China.

Perhaps that's what Copps meant by "unreasonable" discrimination. Copps took it one step further, calling for a fifth FCC network neutrality principle regarding non-discrimination, applied to both wireless and wireline services to "prove the FCC is not having a one-night affair with network neutrality."

In order to get merger approval, AT&T and BellSouth had to commit to the existing four principles, which Martin said then the FCC had no authority to enforce. His sudden reversal on that is, to say the least, interesting, and shows perhaps he embraces the Communications Act as granting the commission the authority it needs.

Martin, though, doesn't see it as a reversal. Instead, he sees it as in line with how he has always felt. "Indeed, I have consistently opposed calls for legislation or rules to impose network neutrality," he said. "Like many other policy makers and members of Congress, I have said such legislation or rules are unnecessary, because the Commission already has the tools it needs to punish a bad actor."

Martin has an eight-year history of boneheadedness, though, and if detractors are right, legislation would be required to give the FCC the proper authority. Today's ruling comes down, then, as a symbolic measure to show the agency's willingness to go to bat for network neutrality principles, complicated politics aside. It's a slap on the wrist to be sure, but it is something network neutrality proponents can sink their passionate teeth into.

Josh Silver, executive director of Free Press, the organization behind SaveTheInternet.com, called the enforcement order a landmark decision and a victory for "everyday people."

"Defying every ounce of conventional wisdom in Washington, everyday people have taken on a major corporation and won an historic precedent for an open Internet," he said. "Today's order makes it clear that there is nothing reasonable about restricting access to online content or technologies. Moving forward, this bellwether case will send a strong signal to cable and phone companies that such violations will not be tolerated."

Comments


About the Author:
Jason Lee Miller is a WebProNews editor and writer covering business and technology.
About NetworkNewz
NetworkNewz editors, writers and contributors focus on both the big picture and the details of networking. At NetworkNewz our goal is to deliver to you The Key To Network Management.





NetworkNewz is brought to you by:

SecurityConfig.com NetworkingFiles.com
ITmanagementNews.com WebProASP.com
DatabaseProNews.com SQLProNews.com
ITcertificationNews.com SysAdminNews.com
LinuxProNews.com WirelessProNews.com
CProgrammingTrends.com ITmanagementNews.com





-- NetworkNewzis an iEntry, Inc. publication --
iEntry, Inc. 2549 Richmond Rd. Lexington KY, 40509
2008 iEntry, Inc. All Rights Reserved Privacy Policy Legal

archives | advertising info | news headlines | newsletters | comments/feedback | submit article


The Keys To Network Management Ask Questions in the Networking Forum NetworkNewz News Archives About Us Feedback NetworkNewz Home Page About Article Archive News Downloads WebProWorld Forums Jayde iEntry Advertise Contact